Fourth of July Reflections: A Canadian Perspective on American Independence Day

As someone who has observed the chaotic yet exuberant celebrations of the Fourth of July in the United States for the past five years, I find myself navigating a complex web of emotions and reflections. Living in New York with permanent residency has afforded me a front-row seat to the fervent patriotism that marks America’s Independence Day. However, it also starkly contrasts with the quiet and often overlooked Canada Day, celebrated just three days prior, on July 1.

Let’s not beat around the bush—the Fourth of July is loud. The booms and bangs of fireworks start echoing around neighborhoods from early afternoon, a symphony of noise that drowns out any semblance of peace. Apart from the predictable cacophony, there’s the financial aspect that’s hard to ignore. If one wishes to commemorate the day properly, the costs can quickly pile up. From lavish BBQ spreads to decorations that scream patriotism, it is an expensive endeavor.

Beyond the noise and costs, there’s a lingering layer of social issues that taint the celebratory cheers. America is a country grappling with racial inequity, issues that become more visible during national holidays when unity is ostensibly celebrated. The stark contrast between the idealistic notion of what America stands for and the reality of systemic inequalities brings about a jarring sense of dissonance.

Now, let’s pivot to a more personal grievance—Canada Day is consistently ignored by our southern neighbors. July 1 comes and goes without so much as a murmur from most Americans. As a Canadian, this dismissal feels like a slight. Yes, our celebrations are more reserved, but they carry equal historical significance. It seems a bit much to ask Americans to remember July 1; acknowledging Canada’s existence would be a nice start.

Both Canada and the United States share a troubling past built on colonialism and the erasure of Indigenous histories and cultures. In Canada, the tragic legacy of residential schools is a profound example of this dark past. The systemic attempt to assimilate Indigenous peoples has left scars that are still visible today. This shared history of colonialism and enaction of policies aimed at Indigenous suppression is something both nations must reckon with.

On a lighter note, if you’re an American reading this, here’s a friendly request: educate yourself on a Caesar. No, not the Roman general—a Caesar, as in the Canadian cocktail that’s often overshadowed by your Bloody Mary. Trust me, with Clamato juice, a dash of Worcestershire, and a rim of celery salt, it’s a game-changer.

Despite the criticisms, I must acknowledge that America’s hot dog culture is something to be admired. Few things capture the essence of summer like grilling hot dogs in the park with friends and family, the smoky aroma mixing with the laughter of children playing nearby. It’s a simple pleasure that transcends borders and cultures.

The Fourth of July and Canada Day, though different in their execution, remind us of the intrinsic similarities between these neighboring nations. From their shared love of national holidays to their mutual struggles with histories of oppression and erasure, there’s more that connects us than divides us. Perhaps this year, amidst the fervor of fireworks and flag-waving, a moment could be spared to acknowledge and appreciate these connections. And who knows, you might even find yourself enjoying a Caesar while doing so.

Recognizing Shared Histories

Both Canada and the United States share a backdrop of colonialism. The settler history is a story of conquest, displacement, and often brutality towards Indigenous peoples. In Canada, residential schools aimed at assimilating Indigenous children left generations traumatized. These institutions, often run by religious organizations and funded by the government, forcibly removed children from their families, stripping away their cultural identities and languages. Many children faced abuse and neglect, a dark chapter that Canada is still grappling with today.

Similarly, the United States has its own history of decimation and displacement of Indigenous tribes. Land was snatched through treaties that were frequently broken, and entire communities were forced onto reservations. These reservations were often situated on arid and unproductive land, leading to widespread poverty and marginalization.

Recognizing this shared history isn't just about acknowledging past wrongdoings, but also understanding how these histories continue to impact present-day realities. The systemic issues faced by Indigenous communities today are deeply rooted in this colonial past. Both nations have made strides towards reconciliation, but much more remains to be done. The celebration of national holidays like the Fourth of July should also serve as a reminder of these ongoing efforts towards justice and reconciliation.

The Financial Toll of Celebrations

Let’s talk about the financial drain that comes with the Fourth of July celebrations in America. The spectacle of fireworks, though mesmerizing, isn’t cheap. Municipalities spend millions on elaborate displays that light up the sky for a few minutes, an expenditure that can be seen as both stunning and scrutinizable considering other areas of need. On an individual level, the cost of hosting a proper Independence Day celebration can be surprisingly high. From food and drinks to decorations and party supplies, the expenses add up quickly.

The commercialization of Independence Day is a stark contrast to Canada Day’s more subdued celebrations. Canadians might host a BBQ or enjoy a local fireworks display, but the pressures to throw a lavish party are much less intense. It’s a different cultural approach that reflects, perhaps, a more understated sense of patriotism.

Yet, amid these financial contrasts, there’s a shared essence of community and celebration. Whether it’s through a grand party or a small gathering, both nations emphasize the importance of coming together, cherishing familial bonds, and fostering a sense of shared identity and pride.

Celebrating and Critiquing

In reflecting on these national holidays, it’s important to strike a balance between celebration and critique. Patriotism can coexist with a critical eye towards historical and contemporary issues. For both Canadians and Americans, acknowledging the imperfect past and ongoing challenges doesn’t diminish the love for one’s country; it deepens it. It fosters a sense of responsibility to work towards a future that lives up to the ideals these holidays celebrate.

This Fourth of July, as fireworks light up the American sky and grills blaze with delicious food, perhaps spare a thought for the quieter, more reserved celebrations that took place three days earlier in Canada. Recognize the shared histories, the critiques that drive us to be better, and the simple joys that connect us across borders. And if you find yourself with a Caesar in hand, you’re definitely on the right track.

Being nice to a Canadian isn’t just a humorous plea; it’s an invitation to acknowledge and appreciate the nuanced tapestry of histories and cultures that make North America what it is. It’s about recognizing the contributions, both loud and quiet, that build our sense of national and transnational identity. So this Fourth of July, enjoy your hot dogs, cheer for the fireworks, but also take a moment to remember and appreciate the maple leaf flying to the north.